Arsenal’s Mesut Özil leaves Ciaran Clark and Newcastle too much to do

Midway through an initially awkward afternoon, Unai Emery was quite possibly bracing himself for the sort of uncomfortable post‑match scrutiny with which Arsène Wenger eventually became so wearily familiar.

Emery’s Arsenal ended the first half seemingly barely able to string two passes together and apparently struggling to embrace their new philosophy of advancing with intricacy right from the very back.

With Newcastle United pressing their guests into flustered submission, Rafael Benítez was winning his battle of wits with Wenger’s successor.

Yet as good as Benítez’s tactical plan appeared, he lacked a striker sufficiently predatory to polish off Matt Ritchie’s stellar crosses and his playmaker Jonjo Shelvey was only fit enough for the bench.

The scene was consequently set for Granit Xhaka to secure an ultimately restorative win by reminding everyone that a moment’s inspiration is sometimes all it takes to undo any amount of perspiration.

If Emery’s introduction of Lucas Torreira helped Arsenal get a belated grip on midfield, Xhaka’s stunning free-kick changed the narrative entirely, prefacing an important – and judging by Emery’s body language, evidently stress-busting – visiting victory.

View image in fullscreen

With an elegant swipe of a Swiss boot, the harsh glare of the Premier League spotlight had switched to Benítez and his Newcastle United side’s haul of only one point from five games. That equals the team’s record bad start under Ruud Gullit in 1999-2000, but the context is entirely different; 19 years on, no one expects Benítez, whose side have already faced four of the division’s top six, to emulate Gullit by resigning.

“We’re not happy, but I’m not concerned because I know my team really well,” said Newcastle’s manager. “We’ve been close, but now we have to make the difference in the final third.”

Emery agreed it had been a chameleon-style Arsenal performance. “In the first half, we couldn’t control the match,” he acknowledged. “We couldn’t impose our ideas and we conceded a lot of counterattacking chances. The key was the first goal, but maybe Lucas gave us better balance.”

Early-season top-tier statistics indicate that no goalkeeper has been more involved with his feet than Petr Cech but, despite this win, Emery’s commitment to playing out from the back remains a work in progress.

Accordingly, Cech and his defence frequently looked hesitant as Newcastle bombarded their box.

Benítez has a habit of approaching games against the division’s elite with extreme caution but, here, he made a radical tactical departure that resulted in his unusually aggressive side harrying their visitors out of possession by pressing them high up the pitch and rudely interrupting their goalkeeper’s efforts to initiate those patient buildups.

In marked contrast, Benítez’s side have played more long balls than anyone in the division – Neil Warnock’s Cardiff included – and have enjoyed the least possession of any team.

Such no-frills directness has, so far, hardly paid dividends, yet with the decibel level rising every time Mesut Özil was bundled unceremoniously off the ball, it initially seemed the ideal way to thoroughly faze Arsenal.

Yet, although Jacob Murphy’s diving header forced Cech into a splendid save, it tellingly represented the closest either side came to scoring during an opening half punctuated by the lack of a killer final ball. Murphy frequently accelerated behind Héctor Bellerín but he and his team-mates lacked the necessary subtlety to capitalise.

Reprieved, Emery replaced Mattéo Guendouzi with Lucas in the midfield holding role and, shortly afterwards, all Benítez’s homework – and his team’s hard work – went to waste, as Federico Fernández fouled Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Xhaka stepped forward to curl a free kick, which Martin Dubravka touched but could not hold, into the top right corner from considerable distance.Significantly it was the afternoon’s first shot on target.

The time had come for the suddenly influential Özil, liberated by Lucas’s arrival, to silence his doubters. When Alexandre Lacazette’s shot was blocked, the rebound fell for the German to apply the, typically accomplished, finishing touch.

Perhaps disrupted by the injury-induced loss of Jamaal Lascelles, Newcastle were unable to sustain their early energy. They could easily have fallen further behind before Clark’s stoppage-time header afforded the scoreline a semblance of respectability, but provided zero Geordie consolation.